The cars | Austin/MG Metro | Austin Metro: The rivals

Austin Metro: the rivals

   Previous Page Next Page  

After many years of trying, BL finally introduced a car, which it hoped would be able to replace the Mini. The MiniMetro hit the market in October 1980, amid one of the most competitive sectors.

We take a look at the MiniMetro's rivals in the supermini class and decide whether it really was a class-leading prospect - and decide whether it's any better as a classic car today...


Superminis hatched

Citroen AX: 1986-1996

Citroen's first credible entry into the supermini class was inspired. Previous efforts included the LNA and Visa, and neither hit it off with buyers - but the AX put everything right, and charmed buyers with its spirited performance and low purchase and running costs. The key to the AX's success was its light weight, and that resulted in an efficient package that went toe-to-toe with the Metro in the late-Eighties.

Datsun Cherry Mk 3: 1978-1983

The original Cherry 100A was a front drive pioneer, and formed part of the backbone of Nissan's original expansion into the UK market under the Datsun banner in 1973. It was a steady seller, but rapidly disapeared off the roads due to rust. The third generation Cherry the Metro found itself up against in 1980 really wasn't a supermini front runner, due to sloppy dynamics, poor performance and inadequate steering.

Fiat 127: 1971-1987

Along with the Renault 5, the Fiat 127 helped define the supermini package for a decade to come - even though the earliest models made do without a hatchback. Responsive engines and fun handling marked the 127 out as the small car for keen drivers, but its cramped interior and less-than sparkling reliability record were major faults. The gearbox was also pretty apalling, too - fun if you can find one.

Fiat Uno: 1983-1993

Fiat introduced one of the first superminis, with the 127, but its second attempt was a quantum leap over everything that came before. The Uno was larger inside and more efficient than all its opposition, and literally raised the supermini bar overnight. As the Eighties progressed, the opposition did its best to create similar packages to the Uno, leaving BL's diminutive Metro behind in the process. Few remain on the roads today.

Ford Fiesta Mk I: 1976-1983

This was the car to beat in terms of sales and design, as far as BL was concerned. The original Fiesta may well have been Uncle Henry's first attempt at front wheel drive supermini, but it scored a perfect ten in just about all area - it was nippy, roomy and cheap to run. The Metro beat it in most areas - except for UK sales sadly...

Ford Fiesta Mk 2: 1983-1989

A major reskin and new dashboard wasn't enough to keep the Fiesta ahead of second-generation superminis such as the Fiat Uno and Peugeot 205. However, it continued to fare well in the sales charts and staved off the Metro, which like the Fiesta was left behind by the opposition in the late-Eighties. In typical Ford style, the Fiesta was available in a myriad of versions and the hot XR2 model sold well.

Honda Civic Mk 2: 1979-1984

The Honda Civic was a remarkable car because it sold in huge quantities to the big-car loving Americans. The first Civics appeared in 1973, and proved that the Japanese were good at innovation. The facelifted model of 1979 retained the original car's charm and precision feel, but added a bit more interior room and further engine options. The saloon version was rebadged and rejigged to become the Acclaim.

Nissan Micra: 1983-1993

As the Cherry had grown up, Nissan introduced a new entry-level model. The Micra (or March in Japan) was a fairly convincing effort, and looked good thanks to neat styling (rumoured to be Giugiaro). Smooth mechanically, it was no great shakes on the road, but soon earned a legendary reputation for being an easy-driving reliable steer. Millions of learner drivers were introduced to the roads in a Micra.

Peugeot 205: 1984-1998

Along with the Fiat Uno, the Peugeot 205 helped lift the supermini class significantly. The 205 was great to drive, looked good and offered a huge range of engines, offering something for everyone. Diesels and GTI versions are the most loved today, but the rest of the range sparkled with rare genius. In comparison, the Metro struggled significantly, although basic 205s looked spartan in comparison.

Renault 5 Mk 1: 1972-1984

Chic and trendy the Renault 5 was from day one, it offered a loping ride and capacious boot. There were plenty of options to choose from, too. Packaging was a disadvantage thanks to its longitudinally mounted engine, which robbed space from the passenger compartment. It was France's best-selling car until the arrival of the Peugeot 205 - and it also briefly held the title of Europe's most economical car.

Renault 5 Mk 2: 1984-1995

Although the 1984 Renault 5 looked remarkably similar to its legendary forebear, the 'Super Cinq' was entirely new. A masterful Bertone dtyling effort packaged new new transverse engine/gearbox packages. A big seller in Europe, but not a strong force in the UK, although the cultish GT Turbo proved a runaway success. Was eventually replaced by the Clio, but production overlapped for five years - Five was hard to kill.

Vauxhall Nova: 1982-1993

GM's first entry in the supermini class came remarkably late - and it couldn't have come at a worse time. Its designers seemed to take the Fiesta and Polo as their benchmarks, and produced a competent car as a result. The class mainly moved on - although in fairness, the Nova was always a more modern feeling car to drive than the Metro and Fiesta. Eventually supplanted tbe Metro as BSM's car of choice...

Volkswagen Polo Mk 1: 1975-1981

Volkswagen's first supermini was a real class act - it should have been, too, as it was originally launched as the Audi 50. Styled by Bertone and featuring all-new overhead camshaft engines, the Polo was a class leading car from day one, despite its small boot and cramped rear seat. Handling and ride were typically Germanic. When the Metro was launched in 1980, the Polo and Fiesta were the cars to beat in the class.

Volkswagen Polo Mk 2: 1981-1995

Volkswagen's second bite of the supermini cherry was a considerably more grown up effort. Its breadvan styling took space efficiency to a new level, and economical Formel E versions established the Polo as the sensible choice in the class. Like the original, it was a light and efficient car, and always delivered lively performance even in the most basic versions. A rational choice in a sector littered with plenty of talent.


Verdict

When the MiniMetro was launched in October 1980, the most talented cars in the class were the Volswagen Polo and the Ford Fiesta. In terms of packaging, the British car had them well and truly licked - offering the same, if not more, space inside, in a considerably shorter package. Interestingly, when the Metro was launched, its styling was considered avantgarde, thanks to its upright rear end, but we all quiclky got used to it, and the opposition followed the same route.

During the Metro's lifetime, that smallness worked against it, as the opposition built increasingly large cars, offering an altogether more grown up driving experience. Having said that, the Metro's cheekiness made it a charismatic drive, and go-Kart like steering and eager engines meant it could punch above its weight as the years rolled on.

The moment of reckoning for the Metro came in 1983 with the arrival of the Peugeot 205 and Fiat Uno. From that moment on, the rules changed - and the Metro was left behind. The nearest car in latter years was the delightful Citroen AX, but that remained on the fringes a the sector dominated by larger cars.

Today, the story is somewhat different. As an everyday classic, the Metro's compact size definitely works in its favour. That A-Series engine the press used to love berating now offers a cheap and effective upgrade path for those buyers who want to make their car run quicker, and a plentiful supply of spares for when they go wrong.

The MiniMetro may have had its faults, which were soon exposed as a new car, but today they werely add character to a great small car...


With help from Mark Mastrototaro


   Previous Page Next Page  

Related pages:

· Austin/MG Metro index page

The cars | Austin/MG Metro | Austin Metro: The rivals